Asmodia's minute is up, now.  And during that minute, she's also thought about what her - Sponsor? - probably wants, from this whole situation.  And while Asmodia's conclusion is mostly that she doesn't know, Ione did foretell the Zon-Kuthon attack and Pilar threw herself in front of Keltham.  That's some evidence - Asmodia's not trying to Probabilize it right now - that her Sponsor does prefer that Project Lawful continue, rather than shutting down.  So she's not hindering her Sponsor's work, probably, if she points out flaws in Keltham's argument here.

"Even if that is what they want you to think, you can't reasonably say that the Conspiracy premise predicts with total 100% probability that some set of girls will mysteriously appear at lunch," Asmodia says.  "There should be a third possibility, that nothing happens."

Asmodia's minute is up, now.  And during that minute, she's also thought about what her - Sponsor? - probably wants, from this whole situation.  And while Asmodia's conclusion is mostly that she doesn't know, Ione did foretell the Zon-Kuthon attack and Pilar threw herself in front of Keltham.  That's some evidence - Asmodia's not trying to Probabilize it right now - that her Sponsor does prefer that Project Lawful continue, rather than shutting down.  So she's not hindering her Sponsor's work, probably, if she points out flaws in Keltham's argument here.

"Even if that is what they want you to think, you can't reasonably say that the Conspiracy premise predicts with total 100% probability that some set of girls will mysteriously disappear at lunch," Asmodia says.  "There should be a third possibility, that nothing happens."