"Carissa, even if you don't just tell them whatever the exact story is, you're not allowed to tell them the abstract form of the answer generalized from your knowledge of whatever the exact story is.  You, Ione, and Pilar are all sitting this one out."

"Asmodia, Meritxell, you're allowed to answer too, this time, after a one-minute pause.  Because an obvious avenue for this challenge, in advance of formalizing anything, to try to say informally what's wrong with my reasoning, and then formalize it.  My guess is that you two don't have as much of an advantage at informal argument, so it's safe to let you out of the Holding Cell temporarily; I could be wrong."

"Carissa, even if you don't just tell them whatever the exact story is, you're not allowed to tell them the abstract form of the answer generalized from your knowledge of whatever the exact story is.  You, Ione, and Pilar are all sitting this one out."

"Asmodia, Meritxell, you're allowed to answer too, this time, after a one-minute pause.  Because an obvious avenue for this challenge, in advance of formalizing anything, is to try to say informally what's wrong with my reasoning, and then formalize it.  My guess is that you two don't have as much of an advantage at informal argument, so it's safe to let you out of the Holding Cell temporarily; I could be wrong."