"A disappointment like so many others."

"Consider this.  Who is not allowed, by the trope, to detect Carissa Sevar by any test, if she is a hidden cleric?  Somebody on Golarion knows; a god at least knows.  The 'trope' does not prevent the fact from being known to anyone.  If there is a conspiracy in Cheliax to hide the fact from him, does this violate the 'trope' because the conspiracy knows it?  My understanding of 'tropes' suggests no."

"Then upon detecting Carissa Sevar as the cleric of a Lawful Neutral god, although it might indeed be very much in our own interests, in that case, to have Sevar renounce that link somehow formed, and make sale of her soul if that was the obstacle, we cannot tell her of it.  Do you understand?  If we now tell Sevar or Keltham, we would not have been able to perform the test successfully in the first place; just as the test performed on Sevar last time, when she would have been told, did not then detect her, somehow.  Keltham would not have arrived in this plane, perhaps the entirety of this reality would have failed to ever exist, if that event could have any other outcome from Sevar's and Keltham's perspective."

"Oh, and in case you had still failed to comprehend as much, Carissa Sevar is in fact the hidden cleric of a Lawful Neutral god, very likely Irori."

"A disappointment like so many others."

"Consider this.  Who is not allowed, by the trope, to detect Carissa Sevar by any test, if she is a hidden cleric?  Somebody on Golarion knows; a god at least knows.  The 'trope' does not prevent the fact from being known to anyone.  If there is a conspiracy in Cheliax to hide the fact from Keltham, does this violate the 'trope' because the conspiracy knows it?  My understanding of 'tropes' suggests no."

"Then upon detecting Carissa Sevar as the cleric of a Lawful Neutral god, although it might indeed be very much in our own interests, in that case, to have Sevar renounce that link somehow formed, and make new sale of her soul if that was the obstacle, we cannot tell her.  Do you understand?  If we now tell Sevar or Keltham, we would not have been able to perform the test successfully in the first place; just as the test performed on Sevar last time, when she would have been told, did not then detect her.  Keltham would not have arrived in this plane, perhaps the entirety of this reality would have failed to ever exist, if that event could have any other outcome from Sevar's and Keltham's perspective."

"Oh, and in case you had still failed to comprehend as much, Carissa Sevar is in fact the hidden cleric of a Lawful Neutral god, very likely Irori."

"A disappointment like so many others."

"Consider this.  Who is not allowed, by the 'trope', to detect Carissa Sevar by any test, if she is a hidden cleric?  Somebody on Golarion knows; a god at least knows.  The 'trope' does not prevent the fact from being known to anyone.  If there is a conspiracy in Cheliax to hide the fact from Keltham, does this violate the 'trope' because the conspiracy knows it?  My understanding of 'tropes' suggests no."

"Then upon detecting Carissa Sevar as the cleric of a Lawful Neutral god, although it might indeed be very much in our own interests, in that case, to have Sevar renounce that link somehow formed, and make new sale of her soul if that was the obstacle, we cannot tell her.  Do you understand?  If we now tell Sevar or Keltham, we would not have been able to perform the test successfully in the first place; just as the test performed on Sevar last time, when she would have been told, did not then detect her.  Keltham would not have arrived in this plane, perhaps the entirety of this reality would have failed to ever exist, if that event could have any other outcome from Sevar's and Keltham's perspective."

"Oh, and in case you had still failed to comprehend as much, Carissa Sevar is in fact the hidden cleric of a Lawful Neutral god, very likely Irori."

"A disappointment like so many others."

"Consider this.  Who is not allowed, by the 'trope', to detect Carissa Sevar by any test, if she is a hidden cleric?  Somebody on Golarion knows; a god at least knows.  The 'trope' does not prevent the fact from being known to anyone.  If there is a conspiracy in Cheliax to hide the fact from Keltham, does this violate the 'trope' because the conspiracy knows it?  My understanding of 'tropes' suggests no."

"Then upon detecting Carissa Sevar as the cleric of a Lawful Neutral god, although it might indeed be very much in our own interests, in that case, to have Sevar renounce that link somehow formed, and make new sale of her soul if that was the obstacle, we cannot tell her.  Do you understand?  If we now tell Sevar or Keltham, we would not have been able to perform the test successfully in the first place; just as the test performed on Sevar last time, when she would have been told, did not then detect her.  Keltham would not have arrived in this plane, perhaps the entirety of this reality would have failed to ever exist, if that event could have any other outcome from Sevar's and Keltham's perspective."

"Oh, and in case you had still failed to comprehend as much, Carissa Sevar is in fact the unfinished cleric of a Lawful Neutral god, very likely Irori."