"Somebody on an ordinary important espionage mission would certainly be corrected in that. By advice and warning while they were on their mission, if perhaps it was not both possible and prudent to send them to a torture chamber just then. By more severe correction upon their return, assuming their souls sufficiently bought that this would not disincentivize their return."
"By the time we get to you and Keltham, we are so far outside the ordinary that there simply isn't any answer by reference to what we usually do. There is still a clear meaning of 'ordinary' Law, however, in that case; it means then not to do what we usually do, but to do what we'd have done without a message from Hell telling us that Carissa Sevar was special."
"Absent that message, Carissa Sevar ends up in this office hearing essentially what I am telling you now, only except without any parts about a message from Hell to be ignored, which is why we are having this conversation in the first place."
"This other Carissa Sevar is then asked to say what she would do about Carissa Sevar's love for Keltham if she were the Grand High Priestess."