Edit History (Oldest to Newest)
Version: 1
Fields Changed (Original)
Updated
Content

"Not bad!  Especially for a first suggestion!  Now suppose I arrange matters such that every token's marginal contribution, defined exactly as you defined it, is zero.  Each of 12 people gets a token.  Any group of tokens from 0 to 10 will produce 0 jellychips, any group of 11 or 12 tokens produces 12 jellychips.  What now?"

Version: 2
Fields Changed Content
Updated
Content

"Not bad!  Especially for a first suggestion!  Now suppose I arrange matters such that every token's marginal contribution, defined exactly as you defined it, is zero.  Each of 12 people gets a token.  Any number of tokens from 0 to 10 will produce 0 jellychips, any group of 11 or 12 tokens produces 12 jellychips.  What now?"