If this was an episode of Science Maniac Verrez than Thellim would be managing to be wrong about nearly but not quite everything while missing key clues in Isabella's presentation because Thellim was annoyed and actually Thellim has been very quickly assembling a very large body of conjoined hypotheses in a way that is not completely nonreminiscent of Verrez at his worst. Maybe it's fine if you do that in real life instead of in a humorous young-adult novel but...
...okay, no, you probably can't get away with that in real life either.